Return to CreateDebate.comjaded • Join this debate community

Joe_Cavalry All Day Every Day


Debate Info

4
1
You go Putin! Bastard.
Debate Score:5
Arguments:4
Total Votes:5
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 You go Putin! (3)
 
 Bastard. (1)

Debate Creator

joecavalry(40160) pic



Is Putin a hypocrite?

You go Putin!

Side Score: 4
VS.

Bastard.

Side Score: 1
1 point

While I'm sure this debate has been set up for humourous purposes, I feel that I should make a point on the subject, considering the range of viral discussion occurring at this time on the issue in question. Also, my expertise might be valued on the events as I've got a PhD in Politics and Imperial History.

In 1783, the Russian Black Sea Fleet was founded (a few months before the United States signed the Treaty of Paris), it was based in Sevastopol at a port which was also founded at the same time, this port is situated on the Crimean peninsula and provided the Russia fleet a strategic control point in the Black Sea and, by extension, the Mediterranean.

It was until 1954 that the Crimean Region was transferred to Ukraine as a symbolic gesture to commemorate the 300th anniversary of Ukraine being part of the Russian Empire, at this time it wasn't conceivable for Ukraine to ever leave the empire and this action also served the purpose of increasing the efficiency of the bureaucratic system as the Crimean Region could be managed by the Ukrainian province alone instead of having it managed by both the Ukrainian provincial management and the Russian government.

It was only until the break up of the Soviet Union that Russia and Ukraine divided, however with the departure of the recent Pro-Russian Ukrainian president it is understandable that Putin fears of Russian access to the Sevastopol port being limited if Ukraine joins the European Union, in addition to this a high proportion of the ethnic composition of the Crimean region is Russian, in the 2001 census 58.32% of the population in Crimea was Russian.

One should consider this points before hastily taking a stance on the issue and before calling anybody a hypocrite.

Side: You go Putin!

Interesting. But I can't help but wonder why you felt the need to provide your credentials. First of all, for all we know, they are bogus. Second of all, shouldn't your argument be able to stand on its own without the support of your credentials?

Having said all of that, I appreciate your point of view. What I get out of your argument is that the Russians have a vested interest in Ukraine. More so than the U.S.. Maybe they can take over the Crimean Region and leave the rest of it to the Ukrainian people to decide their future.

But what do I know, I don't have a PhD in Politics. ;)

Side: You go Putin!
1 point

You forgot to tell us what paper you wrote for your PhD that is related to Ukraine.

Side: You go Putin!
1 point

All politicians are hypocrites, but Putin is the king... the tsar of hypocrites. They invaded, occupied and annexed Crimea in spite of the Budapest Memorandum in which the Russian Federation (together with the US and the UK) guaranteed Ukraine's independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity and they claim the Ukrainians are fascists.

Side: Bastard.