Return to CreateDebate.comjaded • Join this debate community

Joe_Cavalry All Day Every Day

Debate Info

Debate Score:27
Total Votes:27
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 A moral dilemma (19)

Debate Creator

joecavalry(39806) pic

A moral dilemma

You are driving down the road in your car on a wild,
Stormy night, when you pass by a bus stop and you see

Three people waiting for the bus:

1. An old
Lady who looks as if she is about to die.

2. An old
Friend who once saved your life.

3. The perfect partner

You have been dreaming about.

Which one
Would you choose to offer a ride to, knowing that
There could only be one passenger in your car?

Think before you continue reading.

This is a
Moral/ethical dilemma that was once actually used
As part of a job
Application. You could pick up the old lady,
Because she is going to
Die, and thus you should save her first. Or you
Could take the old
Friend because he once saved your life, and this
Would be the perfect
Chance to pay him back. However, you may never be
Able to find your perfect mate again.

Add New Argument
4 points

I'd give my old friend and the old lady my vehicle and send them off to the hospital then wait for the bus with my perfect partner.

Yeah but I wouldn't trust my friend with my $150,000 Ferrari (what if he had been drinking) and I wouldn't want to have to sterilize the passenger seat (what kind of communicable diseases is that old bag packing ;).

The correct answer is to run the old lady over and

Put her out of her misery, have sex with the perfect partner on

The hood of the car, then drive off with the old friend for a few beers.

God, I just

Love happy endings! ;)

I'd give my best friend the keys so they could drive the old lady to the hospital and stay behind and wait on the bus with the perfect partner.

1 point

If i have to choose ONLY one, i will choose the old lady. In my opinion, i think that it is the best choice because you are going to save a life. There is no best choice, but there is a best perspective choice. I believe that my friend will understand my choice and i find it selfish to pick the soul mate because you shouldn't put your needs before others.

I think any answer is the best answer. It all depends on what type of character you are.

1 point

I think any answer is the best answer.

Is there any other reason you would have given it?

2 points

perhaps, by tricking us into saving the old lady, they are hoping to keep all of our perfect mates for themself!

1 point

I would give my old friend a ride...because I know him/her and they saved my life.

The old lady already lived her life...and what if she died in my car and i was accused of murder lol...and how would i know that that person is my perfect partner?!? Bullshit theres no perfect partner...LoL...anyways how would i know they are perfect?!? Do i have super powers? lol

I have to do with best for me... that is the friend who saved my life. I owe him something.

Side: Friend
1 point

Run them all over and make love to their dead corpses....

Nothing wrong with fucking a corpse... you're not hurting anyone...

Side: Friend
Bohemian(3861) Disputed
1 point

Nothing wrong with fucking a corpse... you're not hurting anyone...

So long as you don't contract a deadly virus and then spread it to others.

Side: Friend
cuntyguy2(203) Disputed
1 point

That only happens in the movies. In reality it's probably the best sex you'll ever have. Most women fuck like corpses anyway.

Side: Friend

If the old lady is about to die, then I wouldn't want it to be in my car. Besides on a bus full of people there is a greater chance that one of them has medical experience.

Picking up an old friend from the bus stop on a rainy night definitely does not cover for him/ her saving your life.

In the end I would choose the perfect partner. Only once in your life are you going to find your soul mate.

Side: Friend

I would choose the old lady. If the "old friend" was really my friend then they would understand that the old lady needs the ride. If the other person was really my "perfect partner" then it wouldn't be the last time I'd see them. "What is meant to be will always find its way."

Side: Friend
1 point

I'd say give my car to the friend and ask them to drive the old lady to a hospital (while telling them I owe them once again.) Stay with my perfect partner and ask my friend to go ahead and take my car to my house after they take the old lady to the hospital. I'd then walk my partner to my house. This way you ain't gotta choose!

Side: Friend
1 point

I'd put the old lady in my trunk, let my friend sit in the passenger seat, and my partner could sit in my lap...... XD

Side: Friend