Return to CreateDebate.comjaded • Join this debate community

Joe_Cavalry All Day Every Day


Debate Info

Debate Score:13
Arguments:12
Total Votes:14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 What if the brain is simply a tool used by our consciousness? (12)

Debate Creator

joecavalry(40163) pic



What if the brain is simply a tool used by our consciousness?

Maybe our consciousness is multidimensional but it needs a tool to manisfest itself on a given dimension.  That tool, in the third dimension, is the brain.  When the brain dies, we cannot maisfest ourself here in the same way.  Maybe a different way or maybe not at all.

So the brain is like a computer.  Our consciousness is us.  Our memories are the programs in the computer.  When the computer gets old and slow (like a Windows machine) we scrap it and get something else.  We may be able to take our programs (memories) with us to some other computer (like running a Windows program on a Mac).  Except that in this analogy, the Mac is the tool used in another dimension.  So we may have some knowledge of our life in the third dimension.  Kinda like playing Call of Duty with strangers on the internet and then switching to Medal of Honor on the internet and those strangers switched also and then they meet you and then they're like, "Oh I remember your sorry ass from COD, you SOB!!!" before blasting you with a bazooka.

But I digress...

Or maybe we get another Windows machine and a newer version of COD and continue paying.  And maybe those strangers on the internet did the same thing and meet you in this new version of COD and then they're like,  "Oh I remember your sorry ass from the previous version of COD, you SOB!!!" before blasting you with a bazooka.

Which is why I hate COD ;)

Add New Argument

I don't think that we as a species know as much as we think we know. And I'm 100% sure that the people on CD know less than they claim they know. Life has got to be more complicated than just random chemical reactions, a little electricity and a throw of the dice ;)

Hitler(2364) Disputed
1 point

And I'm 100% sure that the people on CD know less than they claim they know.

You use CD. If you know less than you claim to know than you can't be 100% sure to begin with.

And your point is.... ;)

1 point

I think of it more that our brain is somewhat of the Artificial Intelligence and RAM, our body parts are the keyboard, mouse, and desktop, and our consciousness is our power button. Without the power button, the other parts to the computer wouldn't work. Without our consciousness, our whole body wouldn't work.

A computer can work without a power button. You must mean that our consciousness is the electricity that powers the computer. Without the electricity, the other parts to the computer would not work.

But tell me, what would the enter key on the keyboard be on a woman? ;)

1 point

Sure, why not have some sexy time with that enter key? Mmmm, oh yea… >:)